How to Handle Writer Rejection: A Guide for 2025

By TRWCBlogger

Every writer, no matter how successful, has faced rejection. Even authors of bestselling books have been told “no” by publishers at some point in their careers. Take J.K. Rowling as a prime example—she famously posted a rejection letter on Twitter, even after her massive success, to remind aspiring writers to keep pushing forward.

If you’ve ever had your manuscript rejected, don’t feel discouraged. Being rejected doesn’t mean your writing isn’t valuable. It simply means that your work may not have fit what that publisher or agent was looking for at the time. And that’s okay. It’s a numbers game, and perseverance is key.

How to Handle Rejection and Learn from It

If your manuscript gets rejected, here’s the important thing to remember: rejection isn’t personal. Publishers are not rejecting you, they’re rejecting a manuscript that didn’t fit their current needs or standards. They might even give feedback, and it’s up to you whether you choose to take it into account.

Instead of getting discouraged, learn from each rejection. Ask yourself these questions:

  • Was there any constructive criticism? Publishers often offer feedback on what didn’t work in your submission, from grammar mistakes to pacing issues. Use this information to improve your next submission.

  • Is my writing as strong as it can be? Take an honest look at your work. Did you give it your all? Is the plot engaging? Are the characters well-developed? If you’re unsure, consider working with an editor to refine your work.

  • Am I submitting to the right publishers or agents? Rejections can happen simply because your manuscript doesn’t align with a particular publisher’s niche or focus. Make sure you’re submitting to publishers who align with your genre and style.

The key takeaway is to treat rejection as a lesson. Rejection is only a failure if you stop trying or if you don’t learn from it. Every “no” brings you closer to a “yes.”

10 Common Reasons Publishers Reject Manuscripts

Understanding why publishers might reject your work can help you avoid common pitfalls and increase your chances of success.

  1. Following Trends Too Closely
    The desire to write what’s popular (vampires, wizards, etc.) might seem tempting, but it often leads to generic, unoriginal stories. Readers and publishers are looking for fresh, authentic voices. Create something unique, not a rehash of what’s already been done.

  2. Overcomplicated Plotlines
    Publishers love epic, complex stories like Game of Thrones, but a convoluted plot with too many characters can overwhelm readers. Keep your story focused and easy to follow, and build complexity as the narrative unfolds.

  3. A Weak Beginning
    The first few pages of your manuscript are crucial. If your story doesn’t hook the reader right away, you risk losing their interest. Make sure your opening chapters are engaging, dynamic, and set the tone for the rest of the book.

  4. Uncompelling Characters
    If your characters feel flat or unrelatable, publishers will quickly lose interest. Readers want to care about the people in your story—whether they love them, hate them, or cheer for them. Make your characters memorable and multi-dimensional.

  5. Overused Stock Characters
    Tropes like the “mysterious billionaire” or the “beautiful but deadly heroine” are old news. Publishers are looking for originality in character development. Create fresh, dynamic personalities that stand out from the crowd.

  6. Being Too Preachy
    A moral lesson is fine, but don’t let it overwhelm your story. A heavy-handed message can feel preachy and alienate readers. Instead, allow the themes of your story to emerge naturally through the plot and character development.

  7. Unclear Query Letters
    Your query letter is your first impression. If it’s vague, overly salesy, or doesn’t clearly communicate what your book is about, you’ll likely be rejected. Focus on a concise and engaging pitch that clearly explains your book’s premise, main characters, and what makes it unique.

  8. Inconsistent Writing Style
    If your writing feels inconsistent or lacks polish, publishers might reject your work. Whether it’s an uneven narrative voice, inconsistent pacing, or poor grammar, make sure your manuscript is tightly edited and flows smoothly.

  9. Lack of Marketability
    Publishers are looking for books that have commercial potential. If your manuscript doesn’t fit into a current marketable niche, or if the writing doesn’t show potential for widespread appeal, you may not get the green light. Keep current trends in mind without sacrificing your originality.

  10. Submitting Before Your Manuscript is Ready
    It’s tempting to submit your work as soon as you finish, but if your manuscript hasn’t gone through multiple rounds of edits, it’s unlikely to be accepted. Take the time to revise, polish, and refine before hitting send.

Conclusion: Rejection is Just the Beginning

As a writer, rejection is inevitable. It’s not a reflection of your worth or your writing ability. Instead, it’s an opportunity to learn, improve, and refine your craft. Embrace rejection as a stepping stone, not a roadblock. Every rejection brings you one step closer to your goal.

Winston Churchill once said, “Success consists of going from failure to failure without loss of enthusiasm.” Keep this in mind. The path to success as a writer is paved with rejection, but it’s your determination, growth, and passion that will ultimately make you a successful author.

Stay motivated, continue to grow, and never lose your enthusiasm for writing. After all, your next submission could be the one that changes everything.

ALSO READ: Tips to Getting that Manuscript Published


Discover more from SOI Publishing | More than Publishing

Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.

Discover more from SOI Publishing | More than Publishing

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading